The Illinois in the Civil War Message Board

Re: Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?

My understanding (such as it is) is that Fred. Dyer actually used sources other that the ORs, that his work is more (and less) than simply a compilation of data also in ORs. Supposedly he incorporated soldiers' recollections into some of his unit histories. I don't know how else to account for some "actions" he attributes to some units which are NOT in the ORs. Of course there are a lot of plain errors in Dyer also, which ought to be used as one source among many, not as a final authority.
John

Messages In This Thread

Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?
Re: Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?
Re: Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?
Re: Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?
Re: Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?
Re: Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?
Re: Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?
Re: Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?
Re: Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?
Re: Illinois Infantry at Cold Harbor 1864?